Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Ballard Blasts Lawmakers For Approving $25 Million CIB Bailout

If Mayor Greg Ballard had sat down and thought about how he could deliver another middle finger to the grassroots people who elected him mayor in 2007, he couldn't have come up with a better one than this reaction to the approval of a $25 million a year bailout of the corrupt and inefficient Capital Improvement Board. From WRTV:

Ballard said he is frustrated that lawmakers' latest plan would raise only $25 million annually.

Ballard sought an increase of admissions, car rental and hotel taxes to pay for the operation of Lucas Oil Stadium and other Indianapolis sporting venues . . .

"It's problematic. It's disappointing, and frankly, the state's the loser. It's the state sales tax revenue really at stake," Ballard said. "I was very clear we need to get over this three or four-year hump. Then, we could re-look at it. If we can't do it with what they are making available to us, we are going to have to make some serious decisions."

Ballard admitted that he doesn't have a Plan B, and said the city will be forced to work with what it has. The mayor said he's concerned that the city's tourism efforts will suffer.
Apparently, Ballard's handlers forgot to tell him he could end the bad off broadway act he and his useless CIB leaders, along with Gov. Daniels and Republican lawmakers, have been putting on for the past few months to convince the public there would be hell to pay if taxpayers weren't forced to hand over another $15 million a year to the billionaire Simons per their latest greedy demand. Isn't it nice to know that you can work your butt off to beat the downtown elites to return City Hall to the people and in a flash those same corrupt self-dealers can buy off the politicians who told you they were on your side and negate the results of the election?

In other action, the IURC approved a more than 12% emergency water rate increase for the Indianapolis Water Company. The Ballard administration had requested a 17.6% increase, but the Commission decided the water company's revenue demands didn't warrant such a high increase. I suppose the Mayor will be releasing a press statement complaining about the IURC not raising your water rates enough to finance public works projects to reward campaign contributors and to give even higher fees to Veolia, the French-owned company that was given a sweetheart deal to manage the water company.

Tony George Ousted At IMS

A report sports reporter Robin Miller filed last month claiming that Indianapolis Motor Speedway CEO Tony George had been ousted by fellow board members came to fruition today. Despite a denial by George and other family members of his ouster last month, the Directors of the IMS and Hulman & Co. announced today that Curtis Brighton will become the new CEO of IMS and Jeffrey Belskus will take the helm of Hulman & Co. The IBJ quotes from a press released issued today:

“Our board had asked Tony to structure our executive staff to create efficiencies in our business structure and to concentrate his leadership efforts in the Indy Racing League,” Mari Hulman George, IMS chairwoman, said in a statement. The statement did not specify whether he will be the top executive of the IRL.

The statement continued: “(Tony) has decided that with the recent unification of open-wheel racing and the experienced management team IMS has cultivated over the years, now would be the time for him to concentrate on his team ownership of Vision Racing with his family and other personal business interests he and his family share.

“Tony will remain on the board of directors of all of our companies, and he will continue to work with the entire board to advance the interests of all of companies.

“Our family and the entire racing community are grateful to Tony for the leadership and direction he has provided since 1990,” Mrs. George said. “We are pleased that he will continue to be an important part of the Indy Racing League as a team owner and as a member of our Board of Directors, and we wish him every success.”

A Bailout Is A Bailout

While lawmakers have decided to short Mayor Greg Ballard a few million in his quest to bail out the CIB through a series of tax increases, state tax diversions and loans, the fundamentals of what they are proposing to include in the state budget have not changed. It's still a bail out. It still includes tax increases. It still takes money that could otherwise be spent on education or other more deserving areas of state government and gives it to one of the worst run governmental entities in the state. Instead of making the agency more accountable, the plan further politicizes it with political appointees beholden to the billionaire sports team owners. And at the end of the day, it still positions the CIB to carry out its plan to give an additional $15 million a year subsidy to the billionaire Simons for their Indiana Pacers team. The Star's Jon Murray explains the deal lawmakers intend to include in the state budget it votes on later today:

Under the latest rescue proposal, lawmakers agreed to allow an increase this year in the hotel tax only, boosting it to 10 percent from 9 percent.

The other two proposed tax increases could not be enacted until 2013 under the latest version of the bailout. They would raise the auto rental tax to 6 percent from 4 percent and the admissions tax to 10 percent from 6 percent.

All tax increases would be subject to approval by the City-County Council.
The plan, included in the proposed state budget set for a final vote today, would force the CIB to cut spending by a total of $22 million to cover its projected deficit next year.

That's close to the $23 million in cuts that Gov. Mitch Daniels identified when he unveiled his CIB proposal earlier this month.

Ballard is really getting no less than what he would have gotten under the original bailout plan proposed by Sen. Luke Kenley, which passed the Senate. Instead of getting all three tax increases this year, the state will allow the CIB to borrow $9 million over each of the next three years. When you add the hotel tax and the $8 million a year in state tax diversions, the CIB will have at least $20 million a year more to spend than it currently has. Remember, the CIB hiked its current budget by about $20 million from $100 million to a little more than $120 million. The claims that the agency is being forced to make deep budget cuts are all smoke and mirrors. Lawmakers want you to believe this deal is a real slap in Mayor Ballard's face; it's not. It's a slap in the face of taxpayers. Also, those other two tax increases on admissions and car rentals are still included in the plan. The City-County Council will just have to wait until 2013 to raise them. By that point, Democrats will have completely regained control of Indianapolis as planned by the downtown elites, Mayor Greg Ballard will have a cushy new job lined up for him as his reward, those other two taxes will be raised and the state will forgive the debt owed by the CIB. See how it works.

UPDATE: House Republican Leader Brian Bosma led his Republican caucus over the cliff today. All GOP members voted for the budget bill, while only 14 Democrats voted for it. Several Marion Co. Democrats wisely voted against the bill containing the CIB bailout, which the Democrats bashed in debate on today's budget bill. This begins the process of exterminating the Republican Party in Marion County. The downtown elites have decided there can be only one party rule in Indianapolis because it's too much trouble to control things if you have to deal with competing political parties. House GOP Leader Brian Bosma and Gov. Mitch Daniels signed on to the plan and ordered the Marion County Republican delegation, which is obviously devoid of any ideological conscience, to vote for the tax and spend bailout of the most corrupt and inefficient governmental entity in the State of Indiana. All the talk of government reform by the GOP turns out to have been one big fat lie. I'm ashamed to call myself a Republican today. I hope they enjoy their free tickets to Colts and Pacers games and the campaign contributions, even if they don't care about the harm they are doing to taxpayers. Bosma will continue to rake in legal fees for government contract work. Who cares how much damage he does to his own party. As long as he's making money, that's all that counts.

Here's the LSA synopsis of the CIB provisions contained in the state budget:

Provides that the state treasurer shall invest in obligations of the Marion county capital improvement board (CIB) if certain conditions are met. Provides that the investment may not exceed $9 million per year for 2009 through 2011. Provides terms for the CIB obligations issued to the state treasurer. Permits the Marion County city-county council to increase, before September 1, 2009, the innkeeper's tax by not more than 1% (9% to 10%). Permits during January through March 2013 the supplemental auto rental excise tax to be increased by not more than 2% (4% to 6%) and the admissions tax to be increased by not more than 4% (6% to 10%). Deposits the revenue from the county tax increases in a new sports and convention facilities operating fund for the CIB. Restricts the use of the new operating fund to paying usual and customary operating expenses with respect to capital improvements owned, leased, or operated by the CIB. Allows for an addition to the Marion County professional sports development area to include the hotels in an area bounded by Washington, Illinois, and Maryland streets. Provides for state sales taxes and state and local income taxes from the additional area to be captured for the CIB up to $8,000,000 per year. Allows the captured taxes to be deposited in the new sports and convention facilities operating fund for the CIB if: (1) the budget director determines that the innkeepers' tax is imposed at the maximum rate and in effect on January 1 of a year (September 1 for 2009); or (2) the city-county council raises at least $4 million from the innkeeper's tax and the capital improvement board issues obligations to the state treasurer. Reduces the number of appointments to the CIB by the county commissioners from two members to one members. Provides that one member shall be appointed to the CIB jointly by majority vote of a body consisting of one member of the board of county commissioners of each county (other than Marion County) in which a stadium and convention building food and beverage tax is in effect. Provides that the terms of the members of the CIB expire January 15, 2010, and new members must be appointed to serve terms beginning January 15, 2010. Requires the CIB to submit its operating and capital budget for review, approval, or rejection to the city-county council. Requires the CIB to present a long range financial plan to the city-county council before January 1, 2010. Requires the state board of accounts (SBOA) to do a financial and compliance audit annually of the CIB. Requires the CIB to submit the SBOA reports to the city-county council. Requires the city-county council to review the SBOA reports at a public hearing. Requires the city-county council to approve the issuance of revenue and general obligation bonds by the CIB. Removes the Marion County board of commissioners from the review and approval of general obligation bonds and adds a requirement for the mayor's approval. Makes corresponding changes. Authorizes an admissions tax for paid admissions to certain sports and recreational complexes. Provides that the admissions tax rate is 5% of the price of admission. Exempts certain events.

Monday, June 29, 2009

Judge Nelson's Wife Charged With Forgery

Kristina Nelson is a 43-year-old former civilian employee for the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department who is married to Marion Superior Court Judge William Nelson. She faces a charge of forgery, alleging she forged another judge's name, Marion Superior Court Judge Shiela Carlisle, on an order stopping a mortgage company from foreclosing on the Nelsons' home on Geist Reservoir. Kristina Nelson is also a sister-in-law to Judge Carlisle. The charge by police and the Marion Co. Prosecutor's office alleges Kristina falsely claimed her husband had been shot and that she had her jaw wired shut as a result of an attack on the couple. Kristina Nelson says her husband had no knowledge of her forging the document. The Star's Heather Gillers reports on this strange story:

A former IMPD employee who is the wife of a Marion Superior Court judge was arrested Friday on preliminary charges she forged another judge's name to stop foreclosure of their home, according to the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department.

Kristina Nelson, 43, who worked as a civilian public assistance officer for IMPD, told police she had signed Judge Sheila Carlisle's name on a counterfeit document claiming she and her husband had been attacked and ordering Everhome Mortgage to stop the foreclosure until the couple could recover, according to the police report, which was filed Friday.

She told police that her husband, Marion Superior Court Judge William Nelson, knew nothing about the incident. Kristina Nelson is Carlisle’s sister-in-law, the police report said. Carlisle is married to her brother.

Kristina Nelson was released Friday on a $5,000 bond and faces preliminary charges of forgery, according to IMPD and Marion County Prosecutor Carl Brizzi's office. Brizzi's office is seeking the appointment of a special prosecutor to decide on the final charges.

"Given the fact that our deputy prosecutors appear before (William Nelson) Monday through Friday," said Chief of Staff Helen Marchal, "we thought that this would be the best route to go."

Kristina Nelson faxed the document to Everhome Mortgage on June 17, according to police. The document said that the Nelson’s had been the victims of an assault and that William Nelson had been shot and Kristina Nelson had suffered injuries that required her jaw to be wired shut — none of which was true, police said.

Carlisle told police investigators the signature was not hers but that she recognized the address as belonging to her sister-in-law, Kristina Nelson, the police report said.

Supreme Court Majority Gets It Right In Ricci

A 5-4 Supreme Court majority ruled today that the City of New Haven, Connecticut violated white firefighters rights under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act to have promotion rights determined by their qualifications and not their race when the City discarded the results of an objective, race-neutral examination because white firefighters, on balance, scored better on the examination than African-American and Hispanic firefighters. The City contended Title VII's disparate-impact provision compelled it to discard the test results and justified its disparate treatment of successfull test-takers on the basis of their race. Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority, established a "strong basis in evidence standard" to determine whether an employer is justified in making a race-based determination to avoid a disparate-impact outcome.

In Ricci v. City of New Haven, Justice Kennedy, joined by Chief Justice Roberts and Associate Justices Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, found the City had gone to great lengths in preparing its examinations to determine promotions within its police and fire departments. It hired an outside consulting firm that had developed similar exams for other racially-diverse communities like New Haven. Two thirds of the persons who made up a panel of assessors who administered the examination were racial minorities. The record in this case is pretty clear that nobody objected to the examination until the test results were revealed and white test-takers fared better than minority test-takers. The City used the excuse that minority firefighters would have sued the City for discrimination if it promoted based on the test results, but the City similarly faced the threat of litigation from the successful test-takers if it discarded the test results at the time it made that decision. One of the white firefighter plaintiffs, Frank Ricci, suffered from several disabilities, including dyslexia. The evidence showed Ricci spent money and a great deal of studying for the exam. One of the test-takers noted that, if you studied the preparatory materials that were provided to all test-takers, you couldn't help but do well on the exam because the tested material came directly from the study materials.

This case has drawn a lot of attention, in particular, because Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor authored the Second Circuit Court of Appeals' decision affirming the trial court's dismissal of the white firefighters' case. I should point out that there were also Hispanic plaintiffs in this case, notwithstanding the media's characterization of Ricci as the "white firefighers case", who too believed they had been discriminated against by the City of New Haven because the test results rejected by the City would have offered an opportunity for promotion to them. The majority took no shots at Judge Sotomayor's opinion below, noting that this is the first time the Court has articulated a standard for evaluating discriminatory actions taken by employers to avoid disparate-impact treatment. The Court did not consider whether the City of New Haven's action also violated the plaintiffs' rights under the Equal Protection Clause because it could decide the case on statutory grounds.

It seems to me that the majority, unlike the minority, reached a common sense result in this case. The City had established an objective test that employees could rely upon to seek promotions within the fire department. It isn't fair to those who win a right to promotion under the rules adopted by the City to simply be told their test results would be discarded because it didn't allow a sufficient number of minorities to be promoted. Justice Ginsburg, writing for the minority, seemed dismissive of the white and Hispanic firefighters' rights who exceeded on the examination. Although Justice Ginsberg said those firefighters "understandably attract this Court's attention", "they had no vested right to promotion." That cavalier treatment of the successful test-takers accomplishment is disturbing. It is, however, reflective of prevailing liberal dogma supporting race-based employment decisions. The majority opinion reminds us that Title VII protects people of all races from employment discrimination, not just those who happen to come from a minority group.

Justice Kennedy's opinion is consistent with the Justice Department's interpretation of Title VII in a case it pursued last year against the City of Indianapolis for discriminatory promotion practices within the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department. Approximately eight white police officers had been passed over in promotions in order to promote African-American and female officers who scored below and outside the eligible promotion class. The Justice Department contended the denial of promotions to certain eligible white officers amounted to discrimination under Title VII on the basis of race and sex. The City entered into a consent decree with the Justice Department rather than litigate the case. That decree followed nearly 30 years under prior Justice Department consent decrees with the City's police and fire departments requiring it to hire more minorities and women.

CIB Bailout A Problem For Democrats, If Not Republicans

Again, it looks like those of us who want the CIB bailout punted for good from State House budget negotiations will have to rely on the Democrats. "That bailout rankles some lawmakers from other parts of the state, who are reluctant to support a budget that helps Indianapolis but doesn't address needs in their communities," writes the Star's Mary Beth Schneider. "Putting the CIB in the budget makes it three times as difficult," [House Speaker Pat] Bauer said.

Apparently, Republicans from outside Marion County aren't bothered about bailing out the CIB, just the Democrats. Quietly, several Marion Co. GOP lawmakers will tell you they don't like the CIB bailout but refuse to speak out publicly against it. They simply want to use the excuse that they had a choice between an up or down vote on the budget or shut down all of state government.

The Democrats aren't your friend on this issue (if you oppose the bailout) any more than the Republicans are. The Democrats will gladly agree to include the CIB bailout as long as the state budget includes some lousy items Democrats from Lake County or elsewhere insist on being included in the state budget. It comes down to how much bad the Republicans are willing to accept in the state budget to make sure the downtown elites get their annual payoff courtesy of taxpayers.

Sunday, June 28, 2009

Nothing Has Really Changed At IMPD

A Star investigative story looking into off-duty work performed by IMPD officers confirms the changes the Ballard administration made in response to the OmniSource scandal were little more than cosmetic. In addition to the 51 officers barred from working at OmniSource, the story reveals that three officers are under investigation for scamming 8 Seconds Saloon by charging it for more off-duty officers than were actually working and another officer was reassigned after officers learned he was reassigning his work to fit his off-duty work at OmniSource. Here are some of the ongoing problems with IMPD's current police on off-duty work which the story discusses:

  • IMPD has little control over the number and types of off-duty jobs the police work to help keep conflicts of interest in check.
  • IMPD has no idea how much police are being paid for their off-duty work, allowing private sector employers to buy influence.
  • IMPD has no system for regulating the amount of hours police work in their off-duty jobs.
  • In some instances, a superior officer in the department is being supervised in his or her off-duty work by a subordinate officer, creating the potential for internal management conflicts.

The Star investigation found that 57%, or approximately 874 officers, work off-duty jobs. Officers have been given permission to work for more than 900 businesses, security companies and special events. Bars and nightclubs represent about 14% of the permits issued to permit officers to work off-duty jobs. The report notes that other cities, such as Columbus, Ohio and Tampa, require all off-duty work requests to be managed by the police department. Other cities also set the pay rates for the officers' off-duty work.

In a separate story, a proposal by City-County Councilor Vernon Brown would allow the City to collect fees from the private businesses and security companies that employ police for off-duty work to help offset the use of police-owned cars, equipment and uniforms for these part-time gigs. I've advocated this idea since Ballard took office as a way of off-setting the high costs of running the police department. A fee of $10 an hour, for example, could easily generate as much as $7 million a year in additional revenues. Despite the significant revenues at stake, the Ballard administration and the FOP oppose the measure. They pretend to believe that police officers will lose their off-duty work if the additional fee is imposed, something that hasn't happened in other major cities that have done it.

Unfortunately, the story in the Star really misses the mark on Brown's proposal. What the story fails to discuss is who owns the private security companies that employ many of IMPD's police officers in their off-duty work and what percentage of the work police do off-duty is performed through these companies as opposed to direct employment of the officers. For example, one of the major security companies is owned by former Marion Co. Sheriff Jack Cottey. The private security companies make a lot of money by marking up the price of the off-duty work of officers. It's the private security companies' profits and not the employment of off-duty officers that will likely suffer if the fees are imposed by the City. The FOP has a tight relationship with these security companies and is trying to protect them more than the integrity of the police department or the amount police are able to earn from part-time work. It's very telling that the Ballard administration would oppose fees for off-duty work that could put a real dent in the City's budget shortfall at the same time it is proposing a parking tax on downtown workers to raise $1.5 million for the financially-troubled CIB.

Saturday, June 27, 2009

More On Rezko University

The Chicago Tribune's investigation into how political clout has dirtied up the admissions process at the University of Illinois continues to roll on. It's bad enough that the school admitted woefully unqualified candidates with political clout to the university, but it turns out that university officials also traded jobs for law school graduates in consideration for admitting unqualified candidates to the law school. The e-mail exchanges the Tribune revealed between university officials discussing the admission of clout-heavy candidates in exchange for finding jobs for five graduating law school students is unbelievable. After the law school admissions dean learned that the governor's office agreed to help find jobs for the five graduating students, the dean replied, "Only very high-paying jobs in law firms that are absolutely indifferent to whether the five have passed their law school classes or the Bar." "Sheesk. It's enough to make one want to be a Republican," Heidi Hurd added. Here's a part of what the Tribune story found:

In one e-mail exchange, University of Illinois Chancellor Richard Herman forced the law school to admit an unqualified applicant backed by then- Gov. Rod Blagojevich while seeking a promise from the governor's go-between that five law school graduates would get jobs. The applicant, a relative of deep-pocketed Blagojevich campaign donor Kerry Peck, appears to have been pushed by Trustee Lawrence Eppley, who often carried the governor's admissions requests.

When Law School Dean Heidi Hurd balked on accepting the applicant in April 2006, Herman replied that the request came "Straight from the G. My apologies. Larry has promised to work on jobs (5). What counts?"

Hurd replied: "Only very high-paying jobs in law firms that are absolutely indifferent to whether the five have passed their law school classes or the Bar."

Hurd's e-mail suggests that students getting the jobs are to be those in the "bottom of the class." Law school rankings depend in part on the job placement rate of graduates.

It wasn't immediately clear if the private sector or government jobs were provided.

Gov. Pat Quinn convened a state commission to investigate the U. of I. admissions process after the Tribune revealed that more than 800 undergraduate applicants in the last five years received special consideration because they were backed by U. of I. trustees, legislators and others in powerful posts.

Commission chairman Abner Mikva, a retired judge, said he intends to call everyone implicated in this e-mail exchange to testify before the panel. He said he learned of the e-mails late Wednesday from President B. Joseph White.

"It just gets thicker and thicker and it's not good," Mikva said of the scandal.

Friday, June 26, 2009

Ballard Can't Find More Fluff In CIB Budget

After briefly studying the costs of operating the CIB, something his administration never bothered doing before asking state lawmakers for a $47 million a year bailout for the corrupt and inefficient government entity, Mayor Greg Ballard is now saying the $13 million in additional cost-saving cuts he agreed with Gov. Mitch Daniels to do a couple of weeks back simply can't be done. Instead, Ballard is going to look for a short-term fix to fill the gap--a $9 million state loan from the State Treasurer. What is interesting is that Senate conservatives told me that they added the state loan option to the CIB bailout plan so that Ballard wouldn't have to rely on tax increases. Instead, Ballard is still asking for the $12 million a year in tax hikes, an additional $8 million a year subsidy from the state (strike $8 million and insert $10 million--that's now how much of an annual state subsidy Ballard is seeking) and new downtown parking fees that will supposedly generate another $1.5 million. The CIB previously announced $12 million in savings, mostly from fake budget cuts. I call them fake because the agency grossly inflated several lines of its current year's budget--20% overall--in anticipation of the need to make reductions to win support for the bailout plan. Under the Ballard bailout plan, the CIB will award an additional $15 million a year subsidy to the billionaire Simons for their struggling Pacers franchise with revenues derived from the tax increases he will ask City-County Councilors to approve if the legislature approves the pending bailout plan during the special session.

UPDATE: It occurred to me after I wrote this latest post that this isn't the first time a downtown parking fee has been proposed. Sen. Luke Kenley included one in his original CIB bailout plan. Remember how Kenley was asked about it and he said the idea came from Ballard's people and Ballard's people claimed it wasn't their idea? The two sides then settled on the excuse that the inclusion of the parking fee increase was a typographical error. I guess even typos become serious ideas when people who are up to no good spend enough time trying to figure out how to screw over working class people to help out their billionaire buddies. Also, House Republican Leader Brian Bosma has a column in today's Star in which he flat out lies and claims the Senate-passed budget contains no tax increases.