Friday, June 26, 2009

Oxley Meltdown Continues

Just months after former State Rep. and 2008 Democratic Lt. Gov. candidate Dennie Oxley faced an arrest in Crawford County for suspected drunk driving following a collision in which he was involved, he had another run-in with Indianapolis police last night at a downtown gas station that is raising all sorts of red flags. Despite reports that police found Oxley at the Downtown Citgo station in what appeared to be a drunken state, Oxley falsely claimed to police he was a state representative in town for the special session when police arrived to assist Oxley's 21-year-old female companion, who was laying unconscious on the ground. Oxley, who is employed by House Speaker Pat Bauer on the House Democratic staff, gave up his seat in the House last year to run for lieutenant governor. An online Star report provides the details:

A former Democratic Indiana state representative was found apparently intoxicated at a gas station early this morning and avoided arrest by falsely telling police he was a lawmaker serving during the special session, which would grant him immunity.

Police found Dennie Oxley, 38, at the Downtown Citgo in the 400 block of East Ohio Street about 1 a.m. today. According to a police report, he smelled heavily of alcohol, his eyes were glassy and bloodshot, and his speech was extremely slurred. He was standing a few feet away from Kristin Dowlut, 21, who was lying face down on the gas station parking lot, apparently unconscious.

When Oxley observed police, he began walking away while an officer asked him to stop. After police detained Oxley, he told them he was a state representative and was currently in special session.

Marion County Prosecutor Carl Brizzi said he would meet with officers Monday to discuss the case and whether criminal charges would be filed. Oxley could face charges of public intoxication and impersonation of a public servant, both misdemeanors.

According to the police report, a witness who works at the gas station told police he saw a taxi cab drop off Oxley and Dowlut and later noticed Dowlut on the ground but didn't know how she got there. The gas station attendant said he went outside to try to help the female and tried to get Oxley to help her, but Oxley responded that he was not going to touch her.

Dowlut was transported to Wishard Memorial Hospital. Police did not arrest Oxley, according to the report, because of immunity during the General Assembly session.

The Indiana Constitution provides lawmakers immunity from arrest during session in all cases except treason, felony, and breach of the peace. Lawmakers can later be charged with the crimes.

When Oxley was arrested in Crawford County in February, the initial reports indicated he had a passenger in his car at the time of his collision; however, later reports claimed he was driving alone. Oxley's car still had legislative license plates at the time of the February collision, even though he was no longer a state representative. The gas station where last night's incident occurred is very close to House Speaker Pat Bauer's downtown condo. Frugal Hoosiers identifies the 21-year-old female compansion of Oxley's as a House Democratic intern.

WRTV's Jack Rinehart says most of the incident was captured by the gas station's surveillance cameras, which doesn't look good for Oxley. He reports:

Much of the incident was captured on gas station surveillance video. When officers arrived, it appeared on the video that Oxley tried to hide behind another car, hoping to avoid detection.

Oxley has not been charged, but because he allegedly gave police incorrect information about being a member of the Legislature, obstruction of justice and public intoxication are two of several charges he could face.

Marion County Prosecutor Carl Brizzi said he has ordered an investigation into the Oxley case and called the allegations serious.

"We want to talk to the police officers and find out what was said," Brizzi said. "We don't have all the facts, so we're going to take some time."
I noticed during Jack Rinehart's interview of Marion Co. Prosecutor Carl Brizzi on WRTV that Brizzi credited Rinehart with bringing the impersonation accusation against Oxley to his office's attention. It should be noted that Dennie Oxley, Sr., his father, took his place in the legislature, which explains why police were easily thrown off by his claim of being a legislator.

Just Call Him King

Howard Co. Republican Chairman Craig Dunn referred to Indianapolis businessman P.E. MacAllister as a "kingmaker" conducting his own "star chamber" primary reports WISH-TV's Jim Shella. Dunn's comments came after MacAllister penned a letter to Republican leaders in the Fifth congressional district that confirms the thought process of the elites who run the show here in Indianapolis that I've lamented about so much on this blog. It seems MacAllister has an elimination plan in the Republican congressional contest against U.S. Rep. Dan Burton that doesn't involve voter participation. Here's a taste of MacAllister's letter, which fellow blogger Scott Fluhr shared over at Hoosier Access:

Some of us in Marion County are watching with interest the contest in our Fifth District, where four men are challenging the continuing tenure of Dan Burton. The issue of whether or not this is a great idea is by now irrelevant since the candidates are already in the fray, each hoping to win the primary. The nature of the field may be interesting, but impact of such a donnybrook has every prospect of doing considerable damage, despite the fact “this is a free country” and anyone who wants to run for anything is allowed to do so. If there is ample reason to challenge the incumbent, perhaps exploring some way of lessening harm done is in order.

I have discussed the race with both the Marion County and the State Republican Chairmen, hoping to minimize the adverse impact, but for reasons of his own, neither thinks it wise for him to exert the authority the party has given him, leaving us with a spectator role in this critical exercise.

I appreciate their position but don’t see it helpful. My memory of the last free for all, harkens back to a sheriff’s race in Marion County an election or so ago, which got very bitter, very expensive, and was productive of zilch for either candidate.

There could be an alternative. Maybe pretty wild, but here’s one idea. Let all four challengers do their best to line up support, but by the end of the year, say by Christmas time, allow a panel of 25 party elders, respected figures, influential people, major donors, judicious folks from the district, determine which of the four is the best candidate. Let’s assume we can get the contenders to agree on this tack, which means the three losers gracefully depart the scene and support the selectee in the spring primary.

A letter has gone out to 21 people here in Marion County and includes figures like Jim Morris, Jerry Semler, Fred Klipsch, Jim Dora, John Mutz, Mike Alley, Yvonne Shaheen, Don Palmer, Al Hubbard, Danny Danielson, Bob Bowen, seeking their participation as ultimate adjudicators and requesting their agreement in principal with the idea.

Tom John reminded me that the sun does not rise and set on Marion County but beams on other counties in the district, and including them in this experiment is essential.

Thus this letter to you, asking for: your reaction; requesting your cooperation as one of the “judges” and helping us in finding other worthies in your jurisdiction. The panel, in other words, is a work in process.

This program has to be impartial; has to include promise of total anonymity so no one knows how we vote. It has to include established candidate criteria…past experience, intellectual capacity, persona (charisma), ability to articulate, fundraising capacity, stance on given issues; nature of community support (who is in his list of donors and advisors), etc.

I cannot assure all will buy in. Two of the contenders have signed on, agreeing to the principle, pending details of how it is handled.

We need to contact the other two, but my point will be that this is one way of determining who represents the district come the primary. The inference is if a losing candidate opts to run against us after his peers have declined support and puts his personal ambition above that of party unity, he needs not call on me next spring for money.

Cordially,
P.E. MacAllister



MacAllister, incidentally, is backing Ice Miller attorney and lobbyist Luke Messer in the 5th congressional race.

Thursday, June 25, 2009

RIP Michael Jackson

The pride of Gary, Indiana, Michael Jackson, is dead at age 50. We grew up admiring the talented musician. Our image of him changed dramatically through the years like his appearance, but our respect for his musical and entertainment abilities never waned. Music producer Quincy Jones says the right words: "He was the consummate entertainer and his contributions and legacy will be felt upon the world forever. I've lost my little brother today, and part of my soul has gone with him."

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

Is It Right?

Earlier this year, the Indiana Commission for Higher Education announced a search for a replacement to long-time commissioner Stan Jones. On April 22, prior to the end of the 2009 legislative session, the Commission released to the media a statement saying that a three-month long search had concluded that District 30 State Senator Teresa Lubbers should become the next commissioner. Attorney Jon Costas, Chairman of the Commission, headed up the search committee. Costas is a close ally of Gov. Mitch Daniels, who handpicked Costas as his choice for Attorney General at last year's state GOP convention. Greg Zoeller routed Costas at the convention despite the governor's backing.

At its May 8, 2009 meeting, the Commission formally voted to approve Lubbers as the new Commissioner for Higher Education. Typically, a person appointed to an executive branch position takes office upon his or her appointment. Not Sen. Lubbers. Instead, the Commission announced that Lubbers, who serves as the Assistant Majority Floor Leaders in the Senate, would continue to serve in the Senate until the conclusion of the special session called by the Governor to pass a state budget. Despite the fact that four candidates have announced their bid to replace her, no caucus has been called by the Indiana Republican Party because Lubbers has not resigned her seat.

While the Commission used the excuse of getting the special session out of the way, other political observers, including this one, thinks something else is at play here. It is no secret that party leaders are nudging committeepersons in Lubbers' district to support City-County Councilor Ryan Vaughn to take her place. Under state party rules, the county chairmen in Marion County and Hamilton County can appoint committeepersons to vacancies up to 30 days prior to the caucus, which will not be announced until Lubbers steps down. By holding on to her Senate seat, Lubbers is effectively buying time for party leaders to appoint new committeepersons who will back their choice to replace her.

Beyond party politics, there is a much more important conflict of interest posed by Lubbers' continued service in the Senate. Lubbers first sought the Higher Ed job months ago. As a state senator, she gets a voice and a vote on matters effecting the higher education community, including the very budget she will preside over once she assumes her duties. Ironically, Sen. Lubbers authored legislation this year that would subject former legislators to a one-year cooling off period before they can lobby the legislature. Her bill died in the Senate Rules Committee like many other lobbying reform measures introduced this year. News media reports have documented dozens of legislators, including leaders like Lubbers, who have entered the lobbying ranks almost immediately upon departing the legislature.

In her new job, one of her duties will be to lobby the Indiana General Assembly on matters affecting the Commission's budget and other substantive matters pertaining to higher education. Her legislative contacts no doubt gave her a leg up over other candidates, who have actually held substantive education-related jobs. Except for a brief two-year stint as a school teacher, Lubbers has no education-related work experience outside her legislative service. Lubbers has been able to act officially on these matters throughout the year with her full knowledge she was going to seek and eventually did win appointment to the state's top higher education position. She even sponsored legislation that impacted the Commission this year, which was subsequently signed into law by the Governor. Based on news reports, Lubbers is not shying away from participating in the state budget debate during the special session.

It seems to me that Sen. Lubbers had an obligation first to inform the Senate and the public that she was seeking the Higher Ed post as soon as she applied for the job earlier this year. It's possible she did this, but I can't find any news reports indicating this. News releases on her Senate website make no mention of her being a candidate for the position. Secondly, Lubbers should have refrained from participating in any matters that related to higher education. Finally, Lubbers should have resigned her Senate seat immediately upon the formal approval of her appointment by the Commission. None of these precautions seem to have been taken by Sen. Lubbers to avoid at least the appearance, if not the existence of an obvious conflict of interest.

It is disturbing that nobody in the legislature has raised concerns about Lubbers' handling of this matter. Even more disturbing has been the complete silence of the State House news media. As long as legislators remain free to use their legislative position to trade for jobs in the lobbying and public sector, public skepticism of the honesty and integrity of the legislature will continue to grow and rightfully so.
This is not the first time a question of ethics has been raised pertaining to the Lubbers' household. Her husband, Mark, held a six-figure communications contract with Gov. Mitch Daniels' office earlier in his administration. Mark invested in a start-up company, Strand Analytical Labs, a DNA testing facility, which later received a lucrative state contract from the Indiana State Police. That company was formerly run by former Marion Co. Prosecutor Scott Newman, who now serves as Indianapolis' Public Safety Director. Newman said he placed his holdings in a blind trust upon assuming his new job to avoid conflicts; the company also had a contract with Marion County. Sen. Lubbers actually co-sponsored legislation mandating DNA testing in certain circumstances, which had the potential of benefitting the company in which her husband invested financially.

Wilder Resigns As Council And School Board Attorney

Under fire after being found in a neighbor's trash can by Jeffersonville police following a night on the town, Larry Wilder has resigned as counsel for the Jeffersonville City Council and attorney for the Greater Clark County school district according to the Jeffersonville News and Tribune. On Sunday, Mayor Tom Galligan apologized to Wilder's family for the release of embarrassing photos to the media showing Wilder asleep in his neighbor's trash can. The FOP released a statement criticizing Mayor Galligan for drawing conclusions about the police officers' actions before they received a fair hearing before the police merit commission. Galligan referred to the officers as "renegades" and charged them with violating their oath.

ACLU Sues To Force Terre Haute Federal Prison To Allow Group Muslim Prayers Five Times A Week

If the Guantanamo Bay detention camp that houses suspected terrorists is closed by the Obama administration, one of the federal prisons the government has discussed housing those detainees is the the federal penitentiary in Terre Haute. Well, the ACLU of Indiana has decided it wants to make the prison as accommodating as possible for those detainees should they be transferred there. The civil rights organization has filed a lawsuit on behalf of two Muslim inmates housed there, complaining that prison officials won't allow them to conduct prayer groups as often as they would like.

The lawsuit doesn't claim that prison officials aren't allowing them to pray five times a day as required by their religion because they are already allowed to do that. The lawsuit doesn't complain that prison officials aren't allowing them to pray as a group once a week because they are already allowed to do that. It seems the ACLU believes the thirty Muslim inmates, who are being housed in the facility's restrictive Communications Management Unit ("CMU") at the facility, should be entitled to gather as a group five times a week to pray as required by their religion. The ACLU contends that the denial of group prayer meetings five times a week violates a federal law barring the government from restricting religious activities without showing a compelling need.

The CMU at the Terre prison was established by the Justice Department and houses approximately 40 inmates, 30 of which are Muslim. American-born Taliban soldier John Walker Lindh is serving a 23-year sentence there. The federal Bureau of Prisons established the unit because of criticism it had not been properly monitoring the communications of its inmates. According to Wikipedia, most of the inmates within the CMU are Arab Muslims. The ACLU has accused the prison in the past of racial profiling for housing inmates within the CMU. "The CMU monitors all telephone calls and mail, and requires that all inmate conversations occur in English unless special permission is arranged for conversations in other languages," Wikipedia says.

One of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit is Randall Royer. Royer is a former spokesman for the Muslim American Society who is serving 20 years for his participation in what federal prosecutors called "a Virginia Jihad network." The group used paintball games prior to 9/11 to prepare for holy war against nations deemed hostile to Islam, including the United States.

The ACLU's attorney, Ken Falk, says prison officials let prisoners watch TV and play cards together but they can't worship together as often as they wish. Critics of Falk's view would point out "the increased use of prisons by al-Qaeda and other captured Islamists as focal points for recruitment and indoctrination" as a reason for prison officials to restrict religious activities." Prayer meetings sometimes become a ruse for more sinister purposes.

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Senate And House GOP United In Support Of CIB Tax And Spend Bailout Plan

As a Republican, I'm totally ashamed of the Republicans in the Indiana General Assembly. They are united in a state budget deal that will impose $20 million in new taxes and state tax diversions for the corrupt and inefficient Capital Improvement Board. House Republicans plan to concur in the Senate budget, forcing Indianapolis' City-County Council to contemplate a series of tax increases to bail out the CIB, which has been running deficits for more than a decade, so it can give a $15 million a year subsidy to the billionaire Simons who own the Indiana Pacers. Ironically, Republicans criticized a one-year budget plan passed by the House Democrats would lead to tax increases. The Senate Republican-backed plan guarantees tax increases for Marion County residents and a loss of $8 million in funding for other state programs. It rewards the CIB with additional money without accountability for its past, gross mishandling of public expenditures. Well, I guess we'll have to look to House Speaker Pat Bauer, a Democrat, to stop this tax and spend boondoggle. Thanks for nothing, Rep. Brian Bosma. You helped kill the elimination of township government so your law firm could continue billing hundreds of thousands of dollars to township governments in Marion County. And now the anti-tax crusader wants to nickel and dime ordinary taxpayers to reward the state's wealthiest citizens. Just when I think Bosma has reached the height of hypocrisy, he finds another way to outdo himself. What's the point of the Republican Party, anyway, if it cannot stand up to the CIB and the billionaires feeding at its trough?

UPDATE: The Indiana Law Blog has an interesting post on the state budget bill as passed by the Senate. You can view a PDF of the document here. Get this, it allows the City of Westfield to implement its own admissions tax to finance that stupid sports/entertainment complex their Jim Brainard wannabe mayor has proposed. The new CIB appointments to be made by the legislative leaders should prove fruitful to the billionaire sports team owners since the legislative leaders have all been bought off by them with big campaign contributions and free tickets to games. Also, note that the State Treasurer is going to dump $9 million in loans to the corrupt agency, meaning it will get at least a $29 million infusion of tax dollars. The synopsis for the CIB portions reads as follows:

Allows the state treasurer to invest in obligations of the Marion county capital improvement board (CIB). Provides that the investment may not exceed $9 million per year for 2009 through 2011. Provides terms for the capital improvement board obligations issued to the state treasurer. Permits the Marion County city-county council to increase, before September 1, 2009, the innkeeper's tax by not more than 1% (9% to 10%). Permits during January through March 2013 the supplemental auto rental excise tax to be increased by not more than 2% (4% to 6%) and the admissions tax to be increased by not more than 4% (6% to 10%). Deposits the revenue from the county tax increases in a new sports and convention facilities operating fund for the CIB. Restricts the use of the new operating fund to paying usual and customary operating expenses with respect to capital improvements operated by the CIB. Allows for an addition to the Marion County professional sports development area to include the hotels in an area bounded by Washington, Illinois, and Maryland streets. Provides for state sales taxes and state and local income taxes from the additional area to be captured for the CIB up to $8,000,000 per year. Allows the captured taxes to be deposited in the new sports and convention facilities operating fund for the CIB if: (1) the budget director determines that the innkeepers' tax is imposed at the maximum rate and in effect on January 1 of a year (September 1 for 2009); or (2) the Marion County city-county council raises at least $4 million from the innkeeper's tax and the capital improvement board issues obligations to the state treasurer. Reduces the number of appointments to the CIB by the county commissioners from two members to one members. Provides that the president pro tempore of the senate, the speaker of the house of representatives, and the governor shall each make one appointment to the CIB. Provides that the terms of the members of the capital improvement board expire January 15, 2010, and new members must be appointed to serve terms beginning January 15, 2010. Requires the CIB to submit its operating and capital budget for review, approval, or rejection to the Marion County city-county council. Requires the CIB to present a long range financial plan to the city-county council before January 1, 2010. Requires the state board of accounts (SBOA) to do a financial and compliance audit annually of the CIB. Requires the CIB to submit the SBOA reports to the Marion County city-county council. Requires the Marion County city-county council to review the SBOA reports at a public hearing. Requires the city-county council to approve the issuance of revenue and general obligation bonds by the CIB. Removes the Marion County board of commissioners from the review and approval of general obligation bonds and adds a requirement for the mayor's approval.

AS FOR THE SO-CALLED CONSERVATIVES IN THE SENATE REPUBLICAN CAUCUS WHO PLEDGED TO VOTE AGAINST THE CIB BAILOUT, THANKS FOR PROVING YOURSELVES LIARS TO US.

Washington Township School Superintendent In Line For Hefty Pay Increase

Washington Township Superintendent James Mervilde, who already has a salary and compensation benefit package worth more than a quarter million dollars annually, will see an increase in his annual salary of 7% and a $124,800 boost in his pension benefit, if the township's school board approves a proposed renegotiation of his salary and benefits at its meeting tomorrow night. This comes at a time the school district is expecting little or no additional state funding from the proposed state budget. Moreover, at least half of the school district's middle and elementary schools are failing at least one category of the state ISTEP test.

Dr. Mervilde is currently paid an annual salary of $171,600 under a contract that is set to expire on June 30, 2010. Mervilde exercised his right to renegotiate his current 3-year contract prior to its expiration. He is seeking an increase of 7% in his annual salary through June 30, 2011, taking it to $183,500. The biggest change, however, is in a proposed revision that will require taxpayers to purchase four years of credit time for Mervilde in the state teachers retirement system at a cost of $31,000 per year, or $124,000.

I'm told that this has become a common negotiating strategy for superintendents like Mervilde who are nearing retirement age to ask a school district to purchase credit time for purposes of calculating their retirement benefit. In lieu of a larger salary increase, the additional credit time the school district purchases on the school district official's behalf ensures a much higher retirement benefit for the employee. The school official is not taxed on the credit time purchase, enhancing its value to him or her greatly. These benefits are often not explained to the public to allow them to properly evaluate how much school officials are being paid.

School board member Greg Wright believes the nearly $200,000 salary and benefits increase for Mervilde is too costly. “These are tough economic times for many in our community," Wright said. " Increasing any municipal employee’s employment contract by hundreds of thousands of dollars is simply outrageous.”


UPDATE: If you think this deal is bad, take a look at the deal the Greater Clark County schools gave to Stephen Daeschner, the superintendent who replaced Tony Bennett, Indiana's State Superintendent of Education. Although the school board had a budget of $150,000 for the position, the school board thought the 67-year-old Daeschner was worth $225,000 a year, plus an additional $1,500 a month to sell his home to relocate, family health insurance benefits and more according to the Jeffersonville News and Tribune. The school board's attorney advised the school system it could simply seek private donations to find the money the school hadn't budgeted for the position.

"Larry Wilder, attorney for the school board, said that though details are still being worked out, people should be able to donate to the school corporation directly and anonymously if they want, or to a given foundation that would forward that money on to Greater Clark with their name available publicly, which would allow the donor to use it as a tax write off," the News and Tribune reported. Yes, that's the same Larry Wilder, counsel to the Jeffersonville council, who was found in his neighbor's garbage can last week after a night on the town. Can you imagine the potential conflicts if wealthy parents made specific donations to cover his salary? I suppose that never occurred to Wilder

Monday, June 22, 2009

Hancock County Auditor Resigns

Hancock County Auditor Linda Grass, facing charges she accepted a $54,000 bribe from a relative in consideration for a $238,000 public contract she awarded to him, resigned her job after receiving pressure by a number of Hancock County Republican officials. Grass' replacement will be chosen by Hancock County Republican precinct committeepersons. Have you ever noticed how elected Republican officials almost always resign their office when they are confronted with allegations of wrongdoing, while Democrats almost always defiantly hold on to their job until they are forced from office as a result of a criminal conviction or impeachment?