Tuesday, November 26, 2013

WTHR Reportedly Fired Nicole Pence For Ethical Violations

WTHR-TV abruptly fired weekend anchor Nicole Pence last week just before she was scheduled to air an investigative story on the 35-year old unsolved murder of four young employees of a Burger Chef in Speedway, who were kidnapped from the restaurant and later found dead in a wooded area in Johnson County. Speedway Indianapolis police badly botched the original investigation by failing to treat the restaurant as a crime scene after discovering the unexplained disappearance of the four employees when a delivery man arrived at the store to find the store unlocked and nobody present and cash missing from the restaurant's register. It wasn't until one of the victim's car was found abandoned several miles away days later that police became suspicious. WTHR-TV aired the story, which offered little new information about the cold case after Pence's firing.

FTVLive is reporting that Pence was fired for ethical violations centering around the exchange of information with police handling the investigation. Pence is the niece of Gov. Mike Pence. The Indiana State Police, which has a bad track record when it comes to solving cold case files, is the focus of the story, which claims to break ground with a new police theory of the case. The story included an interview with Sgt. Bill Vann. He identified two potential suspects who may have been linked to the robbery of another Burger Chef in Plainfield who may have been seen at the Burger Chef in Speedway near the time of the store's closing. Sgt. Vann told WTHR-TV that he believed one of the store's employees may have recognized one of the robbers, which is why the four employees were kidnapped and murdered. Pence has reportedly hired an attorney to sue the TV station for her firing. Frankly, I found the story very disappointing after days of hype by the TV station. I thought another TV station in town had done a very similar story a few years ago, but I could be mistaken.

39 comments:

  1. Anonymous8:52 PM GMT-5

    I think that is ridiculous that Nicole would be fired for a similar story that another tv station had aired a few years ago! She was a great reporter and I feel bad for her. It is unfortunate that they would fire her for what they consider an "ethical violation"! Sounds like someone was looking for a reason to get rid of her. What a shame. We always looked forward to the Nicole's on the weekend. Now we have neither!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous2:56 AM GMT-5

      Now you have neither what? Also, ethical violations have absolutely nothing to do with whether another station aired a similar story in the past. You did read the second paragraph, right...?

      Delete
    2. steve morris3:16 AM GMT-5

      I am glad to see her on 59 that's the news I watch ttc

      Delete
    3. She was fired because he's the governor's niece in Indianapolis is a predominantly democratic socialist area

      Delete
  2. As someone who has worked as a journalist, your integrity and ethics is everything. If the reason for her firing is true, the station is right for choosing credibility over popularity. Either way, the truth is liable to come out seeing how Pence is consulting with her attorney. Keep in mind, too, a producer was also fired, so there may be something to all of this.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I often considered commenting on Nicole Pence, but didn't want to hurt her feelings. She has a voice that is like fingernails on a blackboard. I muted the sound whenever she spoke or simply changed the channel.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous5:04 AM GMT-5

      You seem like a person who thinks highly of themselves for know credible reason or your very insecure!

      Delete
    2. Anonymous2:58 AM GMT-5

      Wow, four grammar mistakes in a single sentence. Four! Thanks for responding, Ms. Anonymous Replier. You've brought me a great deal of amusement.

      Delete
  4. Anonymous9:35 AM GMT-5

    It's a shame that this woman was trying to do a good job and bring us something that was actually an interesting story and was fired for it. Maybe, she should have played it safe and done stupid stories like Carrie Cline did at the toy store. Wow! That was riveting Wthr.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous2:13 AM GMT-5

    wthr should hire McKenzie roth from channel 8 who does a talk show called indy today who also does andy mour auto commercials.( wow ) what a fox.she could replace Nicole pence.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous4:31 PM GMT-5

    She had the most sincere smile
    of all your newscasters. Some
    smiles are just too fake.
    She loved her work and one could
    tell. In my opinion you have lost
    your best female broadcaster.

    ReplyDelete
  7. They LOVED Nicole Pence in Lexington Ky.…Loved her…She had the number 1 morning show there. Too bad she gave it all up to go through this.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I loved Nicole Pence and I really miss her and Nicole Misensik on the weekends.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous8:22 PM GMT-5

    Nicole Pence is way bigger than WTHR. Look for her someday on the Today Show or GMA, if she chooses to continue a career in broadcasting.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Broadcasting can be a very political. Sueing the station is not going to get her job offers in Indiana. Maybe she should go back to Kentucky if they will have her.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Nicole was moving up the ladder at a rapid pace. Learning as she
    accepted the new challenge. She will be very successful. I would hope she follows her goals and keeps us informed wherever she goes on her career. God be with you Nicole.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I really enjoyed watching Nicole Pence on the weekends especially when it was Nicole and Nicole. They worked well together and made it enjoyable. Now it is so boring I never watch it and probably won't go back. Doesn't even come close to enjoyable for me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous9:32 AM GMT-5

      I agree they worked well together

      Delete
  13. Anonymous2:20 PM GMT-5

    As a former anchor I can tell you folks one thing, Nicole Pence was the worst talent WTHR has hired since the 90's with the likes of Teresa Tanoos and a couple of others with no talent. Even my wife, who never spent more than a minute inside a studio, said what were they thinking when they hired this one ?
    I am sure it had a lot to do with connections and what a reporter might be able to get with those connections, as it often does in the TV.

    ReplyDelete
  14. unethical is her middle name from friends to work. karma.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Anonymous9:26 AM GMT-5

    I did not care for Nicole Pence from the beginning! The change from weekend anchor Kris Kirshner was abrupt to viewers, and miss Nicole Misensik too! They were a great duo!
    And yes, politics are all over television, that is why she got her job, and I guess Karma made the last call.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous9:53 AM GMT-5

    I certainly didn't care for NP at all. Her voice was annoying and seemed contrived. I loved Kris Kirshner when she did weekend news but I think she chose to scale back her schedule due to her family. Linsey Clutter isn't much better, she stumbles over her words all the time.
    Good luck to NP, perhaps Lexington will take her back.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I find it funny that an NBC affiliate would consider anything unethical.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Anonymous9:07 AM GMT-5

    I enjoyed watching both Nicole's. I have also changed from WTHR and moved to Channel 6 news.
    I'm not sure where they found the weather reporter that is now on there, but she doesn't have the personality to be a weather anchor.
    I watched the Today Show for many yrs. and after the firing of Ann on national TV and not Matt, I will not watch it again until he is fired!!!

    ReplyDelete
  20. The reason I watched WTHR weekends was Nicole Pence. She had the WHOLE package for a reporter. The new girl is awful.You really screwed up WTHR. Nicole is a budding star of the future. You'll make the big time someday Nicole. As for WTHR, YOU SUCK! I'm done with you....

    ReplyDelete
  21. Nicole was great and I will miss her. What's on now is dreadful. I will have to find a new weekend news channel. This is very disappointing

    ReplyDelete
  22. John Garrett12:01 PM GMT-5

    I always enjoyed Nicole's reporting. She was a breath of fresh air when you listened to her. She was the only reason I watched WTHR news. I'll go back to channel 8 now. Good luck Nicole and let Indiana know where you end up next so we can watch you blossom in your career!

    ReplyDelete
  23. love Nicole Pence and I really miss her.

    read or download more about financial info from here Click

    here now :-)

    ReplyDelete
  24. Karma chameleon

    ReplyDelete
  25. Anonymous1:40 PM GMT-5

    The weekend cast of Nicole and Nicole was unbeatable. the anchors there today have zero charisma. I switched to Jim O'Brien and Ron Smiley on Fox 59. There's a reason they're called "personalities".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous5:46 PM GMT-5

      Right, because they're not news anchors there to report, not to entertain. Go watch Fox news if you want entertainment.

      Delete
  26. Anonymous6:41 PM GMT-5

    I say, "Good ridance". Kris Kirshner was head over heels better than Nicole Pence on weekend sunrise. Can't believe the wthr made that move. Don't think it was just about spending more family time either.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Anonymous9:29 PM GMT-5

    Speaking as a Lexingtonian, we do not want Nicole back under any circumstances. She has a terrible TV voice and delivery. Nice to look at but, since she is related to the IN governor, she should stay in Indiana somewhere. She should sue so there would be an investigation into her filing. We need the truth.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Anonymous3:36 PM GMT-5

    I actually went to high school with her and was astounded she landed a job as a reporter on WTHR! It's sad that she got fired like that. It sounded like she had such a great career going for her!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Anonymous6:59 PM GMT-5

    The one they should fire is Anne Marie Tiernon. That one screws up on air more than all other anchors combined. She must be sleeping with a producer to keep that job. As a health beat reporter, I've never seen anyone who can't pronounce medical terms or the products she's reporting on, like her. Truly painful to watch. That's why I don't, anymore.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Lexington blows ass and so does uk

    ReplyDelete
  31. Anonymous6:24 AM GMT-5

    I hope everyone feels better now after throwing your opinions around on something they really know nothing about. But hey. Its the American way right?

    ReplyDelete
  32. Anonymous1:02 PM GMT-5

    To Anonymous: If you were a news anchor like you claim, it's obvious you have a green eyed monster rearing its ugly head, as both Nicole Pence and Teresa Tanoos were why I watched WTHR in the first place.

    ReplyDelete